You Asked, The Gymternet Answered


It’s time for the 172nd edition of You Asked, The Gymternet Answered! We apologize if we haven’t gotten to your question yet, but we try to answer in the order in which they were received (unless they are super relevant and need to be answered in a timely manner). Something you want to know? Ask us anonymously by going through the contact form at the bottom of the page.

Why is aerobic gymnastics not a part of USA Gymnastics since it is an FIG discipline? Is the U.S. sending any aerobic gymnasts to the World Games? Does the U.S. compete at aerobic worlds?

I’m not sure…there are aerobic clubs in the U.S., there is a national aerobic championships, and in 2014, Nicole Kaloyanov won the first world championships medal for the U.S. with a silver medal for her performance. However, despite being a FIG discipline with FIG-sanctioned meets, aerobic gymnastics seems to have its own governing body in the U.S., one completely unrelated to USA Gymnastics.

My guess is that it could just be that USA Gymnastics is a relatively young federation, and it seemed to kind of add disciplines along the way as it grew into the huge powerhouse organization it is today. The national association for aerobic gymnastics in the U.S. was founded in 1983, completely separate from USA Gymnastics at its inception and not yet an FIG discipline, so it could just be that it had no desire to merge with a wider governing body once it became legitimate. As of 1989, the national governing body for aerobics is officially the United States Competitive Aerobic Federation (USCAF), which still predates aerobics as an FIG discipline, which happened in 1996. By that point, USA Gymnastics and USCAF were two distinct governing bodies, so while there was possibly a chance to merge the two, it’s likely that there were logistic issues or just a lack of desire to make this work out.

So while USA Gymnastics won’t be sending any aerobic gymnasts to the World Games, I think USCAF as the sport’s national governing body could have sent gymnasts if they qualified any to the event. I don’t see anything on the USCAF website that has any info about teams, though!

Is any U.S. gymnast currently training two vaults?

The only one I know who is training two vaults with hopes of getting a worlds spot to fight for a medal on the event is Jade Carey. If you’re like “who’s that?” it’s because this is her first year competing elite! She qualified to nationals at the American Classic at the ranch and reportedly has an Amanar and a tsuk double full, a combo that could put her on the podium if she hits.

Who do you think has/had the best Bhardwaj?

In terms of both being beautiful and being consistently beautiful, I’m gonna go with Peng Peng Lee. I could watch her do that skill on a loop for the rest of my life. It’s heavenly, and she has perfected it to such an insane degree.

What’s up with Emily Gaskins and Emily Schild?

Emily Gaskins is still competing elite and was supposed to compete at the American Classic, but ended up withdrawing, though she should be at the U.S. Classic. Emily Schild has retired from elite and is currently taking classes at the University of Georgia, where she is a freshman expected to begin competing when the 2018 season begins!

What are ‘timers?’

Timers are basically warmup vaults. If a gymnast typically vaults a Yurchenko double, for example, for her timers, she might just throw a couple of Yurchenko layouts, and then maybe do a full or two before getting to the double. In the gym when gymnasts are training vault, they don’t just go straight to their competition vaults…they usually work on drills and stuff first so they can work their way up to their more difficult skills. So at a competition, it would be pretty unsafe to just casually bust out a difficult vault, and so in the warmup before the meet, they’ll do a couple of easier vaults first so they can just kind of safely work up to the competition vault. Usually timers are about getting air awareness or the feel of the vault in the air, so there’s zero emphasis on landing, which is why you’ll see gymnasts land them to their backs on stacked mats, or flip out of them…it’s so they don’t injure their ankles or knees on a hard landing for something like a warmup!

Is Viktoria Komova training?

Yup! She is hoping to compete this fall. I don’t know if she’ll be ready for worlds, but she’s posted several videos of herself working out and throwing skills in the gym, so hopefully she’ll be back internationally by next year.

Why are Madison Kocian, Aly Raisman, Gabby Douglas, Simone Biles, and Laurie Hernandez still on the national team if some of them aren’t even training? How does that work?

Gymnasts are technically on the national team for one year since being named, so from the time they were named in June 2016 to the time the next national team is named in August 2017, those gymnasts are on the national team unless they specifically say they’ve retired. That’s why some gymnasts — Brenna Dowell, Amelia Hundley, Rachel Gowey, Emily Schild, and Maggie Nichols — are all showing up as ‘retired’ on the national team list, because they have specifically said they have retired. But the Final Five likely never said “I’m retired” because they have all expressed interest in maybe returning. Rather than say they’re retired and then decide to make a comeback, it’s easier for them to just be like “yeah I’m still going for 2020” and then decide later on if they’re not going to train or compete again.

Typically gymnasts who are not currently “productive” members of the national team don’t receive funding, so it’s not like these five are getting money to not train or compete. According to the international elite committee meeting from last December, “current national team members must attend the January 2017 camp and meet 80% expectations if they are to continue with funding. If current national team members do not attend, the funding will be distributed to athletes decided upon by the selection committee,” so any new additions to the national team last spring — like Olivia Dunne, Alyona Shchennikova, etc — picked up the funding that girls who retired or who aren’t currently training are no longer receiving.

Does Ashton Locklear get the high bar raised for her at competitions or does she perform skills that accommodate her height well?

She’s actually not that tall!! Hahaha…I’d say maybe a little over five feet. She just looks taller I guess, probably because of her body type? Generally gymnasts (or, well, people in general) look taller if they’re like, kind of long and lean? I always assumed Nastia Liukin was super tall and while she definitely was a little taller than some of her teammates, she still wasn’t as tall as I expected her to be. So no, Ashton definitely does not get the bar raised for her. 🙂

It seems the top all-around scores have gone down since the Olympics. Is this due to a decrease in difficulty? Or due to a change in the code?

Both. First of all, the code changed, getting rid of a 0.5 D dismount requirement on bars, beam, and floor and taking vaults down by about 0.5 each to match, so all-around scores in general will be two points lower on average than they were last quad (so someone getting a 58 AA this quad would be like someone getting a 60 AA last quad). On top of that, scores are generally a bit lower this early in the quad because obviously no one wants to be at full Olympic-level difficulty 3+ years before the next Olympic Games. A gymnast with an Amanar in 2016 might only have a DTY this year, and someone with eight E+ skills on bars in Rio maybe will take out a bunch of inbars and replace them with easier skills. It’s not the case for everyone, and in some instances, we are even seeing upgrades, like Mai Murakami adding an Amanar, Nina Derwael upgrading her bars, Liu Tingting going crazy on beam, Sae Miyakawa adding elements on floor…but none of these gymnasts are the top-level all-around competitors, so you’re not really going to see their big upgrades reflected in the best all-around scores of the season. Once we get to worlds, the scores will start rising a bit, and then by the time we get to the end of this quad, we’ll most likely have gymnasts scoring a 60+ AA in the new code, which would be like a 62 AA last quad.

Is Shang Chunsong still around?

Yup. She’s doing National Games this year, but we’ll see how long she lasts beyond that. She seems to be struggling a lot this year with getting injured mid-routine every other second, so she hasn’t really been one of the top-performing Chinese gymnasts and I don’t think she could get to worlds without some major fixes. But yes, she’s still around and training!

Is Larisa Iordache ready for worlds?

Probably not right this second because it’s July and worlds are nearly three months away, but I expect she’ll be ready by October. She’s hoping to do all-around at Universiade coming up, so that would be a great low-pressure meet to get back into the all-around, and then hopefully she’ll be an all-around medal contender in Montreal.

Is a Grigoras the same thing as an Arabian in the new code?

No, they’re different skills. An arabian is a back flip with a twist halfway that turns it into a front flip, and a Grigoras is a barani, which is a front flip with a half twist (there are several barani skills on beam but a Grigoras is tucked with the twist coming just after the salto). They’re both rated the same (an F I believe) but are different skills.

Is Sanne Wevers the first gymnast to perform an Arabian mount? She’s training one now. What would it be rated?

No, Tina Erceg of Croatia performed a roundoff Arabian several years ago and got it named for her. It’s an F.

Did all three of Russia’s gymnasts fall on beam in 2015? What happened in Seda Tutkhalyan’s routine?

Yes, all three fell, Maria Kharenkova on her L turn and Viktoria Komova on her arabian, though I never got to see Seda’s routine so I’m not sure where her mistake came in…I just know she fell based on her score and someone at the meet later saying to me “Seda fell on beam.”

How competitive is an offer of admission to an NCAA team, especially in the top 12 schools? How many athletes have a full ride scholarship vs a partial vs no scholarship on those top teams compared to less competitive teams?

Everyone in NCAA division I has a full scholarship since they don’t give partial scholarships. It’s pretty competitive for the top schools, but any elite or top level 10 won’t have much of a problem getting into a top ten gymnastics program unless there’s a personality clash with the coach or team or something. In general, there are around 700 NCAA full scholarships at any given time, and the U.S. level 10 and elite programs combined are at about 3000 for all age groups each year. Anywhere from about 300-400 of these gymnasts each year are age-eligible to move from J.O. or elite to NCAA, and the NCAA can provide for more than half of those, so compared to other sports like football and baseball where only 5% of kids who play in high school will get NCAA scholarships, your odds of getting a scholarship are pretty good (around 50%) if you’re level 10, and probably around 100% if you’re an elite. So while it’s definitely competitive in some senses, since each team can only bring in a few kids each year and , compared to other athletes in the top levels of their sports, top-level gymnasts are pretty close to having NCAA spots guaranteed (and those who quite aren’t high-level enough for DI scholarships can always get a partial scholarship in DII, or compete for no scholarship but instead for their passion for the sport in DIII).

Is it possible to lose your NCAA scholarship? If there are five big recruits but only four scholarships available, is it possible to take one away from an underperforming team member?

Yes, gymnasts can lose NCAA scholarships if they violate rules or struggle academically. Coaches can’t really take away scholarships for “underperforming” student-athletes, but they can dismiss athletes for problems with attitude or sportsmanship, so if someone is underperforming and is a bad teammate, they can probably figure out away to drop her. They wouldn’t really be able to take away a scholarship from a weaker athlete on the team just because they want a stronger recruit to come in, though. Sometimes teams do get ‘stuck’ with gymnasts who maybe get injured or aren’t as strong skill-wise as they were when they were recruited, but more often than not, these gymnasts end up helping out in other ways that are just as valuable.

What does it mean that Jazmyn Foberg is going to Florida a year early? Did she finish high school early?

Yup! Often gymnasts who are homeschooled or who have worked out programs with public or private schools that allow them to be able to train at all hours of the day will be able to finish school a bit earlier than students on a regular schedule because they might do classes in the summer or whatever. They also don’t have as many credit requirements, because most homeschool kids don’t have to do like, a phys ed credit, or blow-off classes like woodshop or typing or whatever. In the first semester of my senior year of high school, I had chemistry, ballet, “teacher’s aide,” and chorus. In my sophomore year I had “workplace dynamics” which I still don’t understand the point of to this day, and I also had “webpage design” in which I basically updated the school’s website for free. Reading back over this I’m kind of shocked and low key wanna email my old principal and be like “are you kidding me?” Public high school can be ridiculous with random elective requirements, and had I been homeschooled I probably could’ve finished everything in less than half the time, haha. So I can easily see how gymnasts who really only train and do their schoolwork would finish their high school studies pretty early without all of the distracting classes.

Does a gymnast have to have some type of “English” tie to compete NCAA? Can a gymnast from Romania get a scholarship or become a walk-on?

Most colleges require international students to pass the TOEFL, which is an English language test that measures your ability to use and understand the language. Several NCAA students are from non-English-speaking countries, with Germany and Austria generally sending a couple of gymnasts over every so often. Many Romanian gymnasts tend to accept prizes and sponsors at the elite level, so they wouldn’t be eligible for NCAA in that sense, but if a gymnast who was never really big on the elite scene could understand English well enough to pass the TOEFL and had her academic situation worked out, she could definitely get a scholarship to an NCAA program in the U.S.

Who are your top five favorite gymnasts?

It changes all the time, but right now for those currently competing I’d go with Morgan Hurd, Liu Tingting, Nina Derwael, Mai Murakmi, and Ana Padurariu. Runners up would be Flavia Saraiva, Elena Eremina, and Eythora Thorsdottir.

Have a question? Ask below! Remember that the form directly below this line is for questions; to comment, keep scrolling to the bottom of the page. We do not answer questions about team predictions nor questions that say “what do you think of [insert gymnast here].”


Article by Lauren Hopkins

This post was made possible thanks to our amazing patrons who help us fund things like travel and video production as we work to grow the site. This month’s patrons: April, Dodi Blumstein, Wendy Bruce, Kelly Byrd, Jillian Cohen, Kristyn Cozier, Holly Glymour, Hydrick Harden, Inaya, Lauren Jade, Alexis Johnston, Sarah Keegan, Jenny Kreiss, Rae Lemke Sprung, Leigh Linden, Annabelle McCombe, Bridget McNulty, Cindy McWilliams, Alison Melko, Emily Minehart, Eyleen Mund, Melanie Oechsner, Jessica Olaiya, Cordelia Price, Abbey Richards, Kaitlyn Schaefer, Lisa Schmidt, Brian Schwegman, Stephanie, Lucia Tang, Rachel Walsh, and Jenny Zaidi. THANK YOU!

Want to help out and qualify for super fun rewards for as little as $1/month? Check us out on Patreon!

Follow The Gymternet on Twitter and like us on Facebook. 🙂


34 thoughts on “You Asked, The Gymternet Answered

  1. Wasn’t Daniela Silivas going to do NCAA at … either Utah or Georgia but something bureaucratic didn’t work out and it never happened? I remember people saying it was kind of sad, she wanted to continue to compete but it all fell through.


    • Daniela wanted to continue through to the Barcelona to try and win a major all around title before she retired but the Romanian Revolution from the end of 1989 to 1990 caused a bunch of gyms to close down, forcing her into retirement. Possibly she wanted to do NCAA just to compete to some degree, or to “sneak” back into the elite world, but I don’t know.


      • UEG: Can you talk us through what happened in your life after your gymnastics career?

        Silivas: After the Romanian Revolution in 1990 I decided to retire. Things had drastically changed in Romania and I was ready for the next chapter in my life. I never thought I would be living in the United States, but I came here after some friends encouraged me to try.


  2. Omg an amanar and tsuckahara combo! That’s something you don’t see everyday. Has anyone ever had that combination of vaults before?


  3. Actually, homeschool students have MORE requirements than public/private school students in most states (and most do require a phys ed elective). To be eligible to compete at a NCAA school, their coursework must pass NCAA’s rigorous approval process. In addition, if a homeschool student wants to qualify for state funded academic scholarships for college they have to have HIGHER SAT/ACT scores than their public/private peers. However, you are correct in the fact that their courses are more applicable to them because they don’t have to deal with scheduling issues and can finish courses more quickly because they are spending their time actually studying rather than navigating a typical school day.


    • Yeah, that’s what I meant — that classwork is more relevant and that they don’t have to deal with a lot of the nonsense of public schools. I didn’t mean that homeschool was easier — just that there’s less BS to deal with, and once the fluff is gone, you’re able to actually focus and get things done way faster, especially if you’re working through the summer. I was homeschooled for a semester of high school (well, “on the road”-schooled, it was while on a national tour in a musical) and I got everything done in probably 25% of the time I was able to get things done in actual school because I was an independent learner and I felt that a lot of the classroom nonsense was just killing time (like, do we really need to act out “Romeo and Juliet” with everyone taking the entire 90 minutes to read a simple scene because there’s giggling and tom foolery when I could’ve read the whole play on my own?). My electives while homeschooled were AP classes. My high school didn’t offer those but did offer about 100 nonsense classes that made no sense. And I read that most athletes who homeschool don’t have to do a phys ed credit because their sport counts as that basically.


  4. Unless I missed something, isn’t Sanne Wevers competing a roundoff, Onodi mount and not an Arabian? And if so, she wouldn’t be the first to perform as Jacqui Dunn of Australia performed it back it 2003 and got it named after her.


  5. I actually do think some NCAA gymnasts are on partial scholarships. Gymnastics is a head count sport, so at most only 12 people can have scholarships but they’re not full all the time. Not all programs have full funding. If school X has a $400,000 scholarship budget and tuition is $40,000, the coach can either give 10 athletes full rides or split them up between 12 people.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Also walk-ons at DI schools don’t have scholarships usually, although of course some eventually preform well enough to get them, and lots of teams have walk-ons who make lineups. I thought each DI NCAA school had a specific number of scholarships to award, but that they could have as many walk-ons as they wanted.


      • Yeah I was really confused by how she worded it too. It sounds like she’s basically saying everyone that is on a D1 team is on scholarship, but we all know walk on totally happen everywhere. But what I think she was trying to say is that everyone at D1 schools with a scholarship has a full ride, not partial. But I really didn’t think this was the case. Is that really true. Either you’re full scholarship or walk on basically? And for some reason I thought the number of scholarships they can offer was limited by the NCAA and wasn’t a huge number, or maybe it was based on money, but either way, wouldn’t you get more by splitting some and offering partial scholarships?


        • Yes, you’re either a full scholarship or a walk-on. Not all D1s give scholarships, so that comment is right — I went to a D1 that was ivy league and so our athletes didn’t get scholarships. But no D1 schools give partial scholarships, at least not for gymnastics.


  6. Re athletes who are actually upgrading in the post-Olympic year–I wonder if this could be strategic. With many big players out of the way, maybe small programs can get a better chance of a worlds medal if they focus on upgrades this year rather than setting sights on the Olympics. To gymnerds a worlds medal I think has less clout if it’s a post-Olympic year, but I wonder if for increasing funding it doesn’t matter to federations. The medals aren’t as prestigious as Olympic medals, but they may be all a federation can hope for. I’m totally just speculating here, though.


    • Completely agree with that. With much less competition, this is the best chance for many gymnasts to make it big at worlds and hopefully win some medals. By 2020, everyone will be on top of their game and it will be much more difficult to make an event finals, much less win a medal.


  7. Quick correction: Komova plans to compete by December for the Voronin Cup, not the fall. Rodienko wants her to compete in August if ready, and has repeated that several times, but Komova has remained firm in her position that she will not compete before December.


  8. Just a *small* correction – not all Div 1 schools offer scholarships. The Ivy League, which is Div 1, is not allowed to award athletic (or academic) scholarships. For gymnastics, Yale, Brown, Cornell, and Penn have teams, and none of them are on scholarship. Teams are generally composed of Level 9s through former elite.


    • That someone is Norah; on her instagram she has a lengthy post thanking everyone who has helped her through her elite career and her retirement announcement. For the next year she will train and compete Level 10 routines before heading off to UCLA.


      • Sounds very Ohashi esque. Did she have a serious injury that didnt allow her to perform as difficulty routines? Sucks. She was co clean


        • No need. You can see she’s the exact same height or slightly shorter than most of her teammates on the cover of the classic senior guide. Considering gymnasts at the elite level are typically 5’1-5’2, she’s probably right around there. Ashton appears taller because she’s slender for one, and her legs are proportionally long.

          Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s