Germany Defeats Romania in Friendly Meet


Earlier today, Germany beat Romania by just about one full point at Länderkampf Kunstturnen in Obersiggenthal, Switzerland, highlighting just how much of a jam Romania could be in at World Championships next month.

Both teams used the athletes who should be set to compete in Nanning, with a few small alterations for Germany. As they are still deciding between two athletes for the sixth spot on their team, they chose to give Worlds team member Cagla Akyol the day off in order to use this meet as a trial for Elisabeth Seitz on bars and Leah Griesser on beam and floor.

Larisa Iordache performed wonderfully, winning the all-around, vault, beam, and floor titles. But she will have to keep up consistent all-around performances in Nanning, putting the bulk of this team’s weight on her tiny shoulders, which could be too much pressure for her.

The team didn’t perform horribly, exactly, and had this been a three count situation like it will be at Worlds (it was four count here), Romania would have defeated Germany by three tenths. That doesn’t inspire much confidence, as two years ago Romania had ten full points over Germany.

Of course, they lost superstars Sandra Izbasa and Catalina Ponor to retirement, Diana Bulimar is injured, and the bulk of their junior talent won’t join the senior ranks until next year, so they’re not officially crying for help just yet. This year is little more than a blip on the radar for them, but it still has the potential to be painful at Worlds, where Germany, Japan, Italy, and especially Great Britain have the potential to outscore them.

Looking at the numbers, Romania has big potential on vault (where they have two DTYs) and beam (where Iordache and Andreea Munteanu have incredible routines). They’re good, if not fantastic, on floor…but their bars is absolutely dismal and brings their event total average down by a full point.

Iordache looks much improved, and earned a 14.45 in the competition today, good enough for third place behind Germany’s insanely talented bar workers. But the next-highest score was Stefania Stanila’s 12.95, and behind her, Ana Maria Ocolisan brought in a 12.4 while Paula Tudorache earned a 10.2.

Not counting that 10.2 would have helped in the team final, so the odds do look better in a three-up situation, but honestly, not by much. They are going to have to do absolutely everything they can in qualifications at Worlds to make sure they’re at the top, though at this point, knowing how much other teams are bringing to the table, it’s not going to be easy for them to stay inside that Big Four bubble.

What about Germany? They’re not exactly without problems, but they have no major margin of error like Romania has on bars. Beam and floor aren’t exactly outstanding, but they can put up three very clean vaults and their bars are fantastic…between Lisa Hill, Kim Bui, and Sophie Scheder, they’re very solid on this event, but possibly having Seitz back just gives them added security.

Seitz didn’t have her best bar routine today, but it was her first routine after a very long time away from competition due to multiple injuries. She must still contend for the final spot on the German World Championships team along with Griesser, who competed today on beam and floor.

The German team needs beam and floor more than they need an additional bar worker, but I’m not fully sold on Griesser. She was fifth out of the five Germans who competed on beam with just an 11.45, and her floor was okay but not enough to save them – she brought in a 13.15, the third best for the Germans behind Bui and Pauline Schäfer. However, Hill didn’t compete on floor for some reason, and Akyol wasn’t at this meet. Both can contribute higher scores here than Griesser can.

As it looks, the sixth German to be added will be extraneous. If they go with Seitz, they’ll have possible insurance on bars, but if they go with Griesser, they’ll have a utility player on the two events with which they need the most help. Seitz is older and more experienced, Griesser is younger but won’t get the experience she needs for the future if they don’t use her here. It’s a much more difficult decision than I thought it’d be, though I think at this point I’d go with Griesser if only so Seitz can have some time off to recover rather than putting unneeded stress on her body when she won’t even contribute much more than they already have.

The rest of their team looks to be doing well, even if Scheder had a rough day. Bui and Schäfer were neck-in-neck in the all-around, with Schäfer edging out the German national champion by two tenths to secure the bronze all-around medal. Hill put up a gorgeous FTY, a solid beam set, and a rock star bars routine, winning the title on that event. Had she competed on floor, she would have been right up there with Schäfer and Bui. It’s a very good team, and with the addition of Akyol for Worlds should compete very well in Nanning.

Host team Switzerland came in third here, as expected. Giulia Steingruber took the silver all-around medal with clean and steady performances across all events. Ilaria Käslin proved what a great help she will be on bars and beam, events on which Caterina Barloggio also showed to compete well, if not coming in with the highest difficulty.

Overall, the Länderkampf Kunstturnen meet offered a nice glimpse at what we should expect from these three teams at World Championships. Romania will want to spend the next few weeks really trying to build consistency among their younger athletes, if only because right now Iordache is the glue holding that team together. If something happens with an injury or falls in qualifications, this team will be lucky to make it into the team final. It’s looking that bleak.

All-Around Results

 Rank Athlete Nation VT UB BB FX AA
 1 Larisa Iordache Romania 14.800 14.450 15.100 14.600 58.950
2 Giulia Steingruber Switzerland 14.450 13.900 14.250 14.100 56.700
3 Pauline Schäfer Germany 14.400 13.050 14.250 13.900 55.600
4 Kim Bui Germany 13.750 14.600 12.600 14.450 55.400
5 Stefania Stanila Romania 13.600 12.950 13.600 14.000 54.150
6 Sophie Scheder Germany 13.800 14.150 13.050 11.750 52.750
7 Stefanie Siegenthaler Switzerland 12.800 12.900 12.950 11.700 50.350
8 Lisa Katharina Hill Germany 14.150 14.650 13.400 —— 42.200
9 Ana Maria Ocolisan Romania 14.600 12.400 13.200 —— 40.200
10 Laura Schulte Switzerland 13.900 12.250 —— 12.550 38.700
11 Caterina Barloggio Switzerland —— 12.900 13.200 12.250 38.350
12 Nicole Hitz Switzerland 13.050 —— 12.650 12.050 37.750
13 Paula Tudorache Romania —— 10.200 12.350 13.250 35.800
14 Andreea Munteanu Romania —— —— 14.450 13.900 28.350
15 Silvia Zarzu Romania 13.750 —— —— 13.450 27.200
16 Ilaria Käslin Switzerland —— 13.300 13.850 —— 27.150
17 Leah Griesser Germany —— —— 11.450 13.150 24.600
18 Elisabeth Seitz Germany —— 13.950 —— —— 13.950

Team Results

 Rank Nation Total
1 Germany 220.000
2 Romania 219.050
3 Switzerland 212.400

Article by Lauren Hopkins
Photo thanks to Deutscher Turner-Bund

9 thoughts on “Germany Defeats Romania in Friendly Meet

  1. Pingback: Germany over Romania — Gymnastics

  2. Man- Romania really is in a bind this year. They’re definitely counting down the days until Iridon and Jurca can join the senior ranks. I think they’ll revitalize the team and really put them back into the top.


  3. The Romanians somewhat downgraded their routines in this meet. For example, Stanila and Zarzu did not do their DTYs and Iordache did not do her full floor routine. But yeah Worlds is going to be hard not because it’s a terrible team, but because they’re lacking on bars so much. Qualifications at Worlds will bring them down because besides Stanila and Iordache, the rest of the girls can only really contribute on 1 or 2 events. Plus their bars total will be really low so they can’t afford a fall anywhere….

    I don’t know, regardless, I will always root for the Romanians. I don’t think it’s so bad that they’ll be struggling to even qualify, but I’m hoping for the best.


  4. “they chose to give Worlds team member Cagla Akyol the day off” – Cagla was sick (see, normally she would have competed


    • True but they were going to choose one Worlds member to sit out so they could test Leah and Eli. Cagla happened to be sick so it ended up being her, but a huge purpose of this meet was a trial for the sixth spot.


      • I know that. Still, Akyol was scheduled to compete there (someone would have gone as an individual, just like Schulze did now) and your wording makes it sound like they just decided to let her off the team. They all were supposed to compete, Akyol, Seitz and Grießer.

        Don’t get me wrong, I love your work, I just thought I’d clarify!


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s