The Montreal Vault Preview

rebecaandrade1_cbg_ricardobufolin

Over the next five days I’m excited to bring you a preview for every individual event final at next week’s world championships in Montreal.

We’re starting things off with vault, which over the past few years has generally been a battle for those with that super difficult combination of the Amanar and Cheng, but now it’s kind of an open book.

Our reigning world champion, Maria Paseka, is hoping to defend her title and will possibly be at her full Amanar and Cheng difficulty, but she’s had kind of a disastrous international season, missing what should’ve been easy golds at both European Championships and the Summer Universiade.

It’s kind of hard to say what she can or will do in Montreal. One day she’s hitting Amanars no problem, and literally the next, she’s crashing them. Her highest vault average of 14.625, which she got at Universiade qualifications, is totally medal-worthy, but her lowest average of 13.916 from Universiade finals wouldn’t even get her into the final.

Where she finishes will all depend on the level of difficulty she competes and how she ends up looking on the day that it counts. With an Amanar and a Cheng done well, she’s in the mix for gold, and if she downgrades the Cheng to the Lopez, as she’s done a couple of times this year, she’s in the mix for the podium. Even with her generally weak form, her difficulty has always been able to carry her through when she hits, but it’s whether she hits or not that’s up in the air.

I am all about Rebeca Andrade of Brazil winning the gold. I’m really into this thing called execution, and if that’s the only thing that mattered, Andrade wins it hands down. The 2016 Olympian earned two challenge cup titles on the event this year, one with a DTY and Lopez, and then in Varna a few weeks ago, she upgraded to an Amanar, with her 15.15 for that vault getting the highest single vault score of the year.

Andrade also boasts the highest international vault average with a 14.8 in Varna’s event finals, and her E scores are consistently above a 9, with at least five of this year’s vaults earning a 9.3 or better. Andrade has spent much of her senior career dealing with injuries that have kept her from being at her best on leg events, but she’s showing this year just how good she can be, and I physically need her to win this title.

While Andrade has the highest international vault average this season, the highest average overall belongs to Sae Miyakawa of Japan, who gets just a half tenth ahead of Andrade with her 14.85 from this summer’s All-Japan Event Championships. Miyakawa has a super difficult Rudi and DTY combination, and she’s capable of reaching a 15 with her Rudi.

She’s not necessarily the cleanest vaulter, but I think Andrade aside, this isn’t currently an event with a million Simone Biles clones. Everyone has some “form stuff” going on, whether that’s loose knees or landing short or a rough pre-flight. Miyakawa does look better than most, and so I think she will end up being someone who can really challenge here this year.

Then you have Jade Carey of the United States, whose highest vault average is barely in the top eight, and yet her difficulty is tied for the top in the world with her combination of Amanar and tsuk double. She struggled a bit at nationals with both of these, but looked much-improved at last week’s camp and I think when the judges at worlds see her directly next to her competition, she’ll end up being one of the podium contenders.

Wang Yan of China is the only gymnast at worlds who matches Carey’s difficulty combo of 11.4 with her tsuk double and Rudi combo, and like Carey, form issues sometimes hold her back. Wang has also been dealing with an injury that kept her out of the Doha and Chinese national finals, but she looked much-improved and in good health at the recent National Games, and she made a huge impression with her fifth-place finish at the Olympics last summer, so I think she’s definitely another who could sneak onto the podium.

Another favorite for a medal could be Shallon Olsen of the host country Canada. Olsen, who placed eighth on vault in Rio, could have the second-highest difficulty combination if she upgrades her DTY to an Amanar, but even without the upgrade she’s still boasting a 10.8 for her DTY and Khorkina. Her problem with or without an Amanar, however, is her execution. While her domestic averages are consistently around a 14.3 to 14.5, her international averages range from 14.15 to 14.225, which just won’t be competitive in this field. Unless her form is magically stronger, she won’t factor in without the Amanar, and even with the Amanar her form could again be what holds her back.

Olsen’s teammate Ellie Black will be another local favorite, and she’s worth a mention here even though I’m not sure how realistic a medal will be. She has a combined 10.6 difficulty thanks to her handspring front layout full and a tsuk 1½, but like Olsen, she struggles a bit with doing these vaults as well as some of the other top vaulters are hitting, and she missed out on the podium at Universiade with big mistakes on both. If she hits, she could definitely make it into the final, but with so much depth, it’s not going to be easy.

Seven-time Olympian and legend Oksana Chusovitina of Uzbekistan is in a similar situation as Black in that she could be borderline for making this final due to a lack of attention to her form in a pretty deep field. If she looks like she did in the spring, competing the same handspring front layout full and a tsuk 1½, she could be in the mix, but in recent weeks she’s been downgraded on both, to a handspring layout half and a tsuk full (and the judges downgrade her handspring layout half even further due to her form, crediting only a pike). I wouldn’t ever count her out, though. She always upgrades when she needs to, and I wouldn’t be surprised to see her Rudi magically reappear in Montreal, putting her right back in contention.

We also can’t ignore the European champion Coline Devillard of France, who has a Rudi and DTY for a combined D score of 11.2. Her form leaves much to be desired, and at Euros it actually looked like one of the cleaner ‘DTY and Lopez’ vaulters might beat her, but in the end, she had a solid day and got the win. But again, there is so much difficulty and depth in this final, and with other gymnasts able to match her on the difficulty level, she’ll have to do just a little bit more to challenge here.

Okay, that’s nine gymnasts who all have what it takes to make the vault final, and that’s before we even get to all of the DTY and Lopez combo vaulters. This group includes European bronze medalist Boglarka Devai of Hungary, Angelina Melnikova of Russia, Tisha Volleman of the Netherlands, and Tabea Alt of Germany, who just recently added a Lopez to her arsenal to earn a spot in this squad.

Unfortunately, the best of the DTY and Lopez vaulters, Ellie Downie, will miss worlds due to a recent surgery, but among the rest I think we could definitely see one or two of the cleaner vaulters get in ahead over someone with greater difficulty. They’re all on the outskirts right now, but it’s not always about difficulty. Alt looked especially clean at Germany’s world trials, and Melnikova also showed great improvement at the Russian Cup, so I wouldn’t count them out just because they’re not doing insane difficulty.

I also have two kind of wildcard favorites for this final. It’s hard to ignore any Amanar, and Mai Murakami of Japan just might whip hers out this year after giving it a shot at a domestic meet this summer. She hit the vault in training, but sat it in competition, though when paired with a tsuk full she has a combination that makes her an outside contender for the final, so it would be cool to see her sneak in when not really being expected to do so.

Finally, there’s world cup star Teja Belak of Slovenia, who picked up the bronze medals on vault in Baku, Doha, Koper, and Varna this year, though unfortunately, falls in Szombathely and Paris kept her from making the final. Belak’s difficulty isn’t the greatest, but when she hits her handspring layout full and Yurchenko 1½ well, she’s capable of great scores. Average-wise, she maxes out in the low 14s, with a 14.183 in finals at European Championships her best this year, but I’m a big fan of the old “anything can happen” law in gymnastics, and am crossing my fingers for Belak to make the first world championships final of her career.

The only other gymnast who has so far come nowhere close to this field but is in a category of her own as someone who last year boasted a DTY and a Rudi is Olympic bronze medalist Giulia Steingruber, who had surgery and took an extended break this year with the goal of returning for next year’s Euros, though she made a surprise appearance at nationals and was named to the worlds team shortly after. At nationals, Steingruber cut down her difficulty considerably, but if she can magically bring back some of her stronger vaults for worlds, she could absolutely be a surprise.

Oh, and I need to throw Marcia Vidiaux of Cuba into this pool as well. A fall in qualifications at the Olympic Games kept her from making the final, but if she’s at full strength, she’s right up there both in terms of her difficulty and execution. Unfortunately, we don’t see the Cuban gymnasts all that often so we have very little to go on with her, but keep her in your noggin just in case.

From 2016, we’re sadly missing Olympic champion Simone Biles, who plans on returning to gymnastics in the near future, Hong Un Jong of North Korea (which is abstaining from competing at worlds this year), history-making Dipa Karmakar of India (she’s dealing with knee injury rehab and hopes to be back for the Commonwealth Games next year), Canada’s Brittany Rogers (who did not make this year’s worlds team), Seda Tutkhalyan of Russia (who has been injured and not at full strength this year), and Alexa Moreno of Mexico (who hasn’t yet returned to competition, though plans on it).

No preview of ours is complete without stone-cold data, so check us out below for a “by the numbers” look at everyone who will contend for the vault final (note that we’re only including those who are confirmed to compete at worlds, so while gymnasts like Liu Jinru of China may be at the top of some of these lists, because they won’t be in Montreal, they’re not included here).

By the Numbers | Best Combined Vault Averages

Rank Athlete Nation Meet Score
1 Sae Miyakawa Japan All-Japan Event Championships EF 14.850
2 Rebeca Andrade Brazil Varna EF 14.800
3 Maria Paseka Russia Universiade QF 14.625
4 Wang Yan China Doha QF 14.566
5 Angelina Melnikova Russia Russian Cup QF 14.525
Ellie Black Canada Universiade QF 14.525
7 Shallon Olsen Canada City of Jesolo Trophy EF 14.500
8 Jade Carey United States U.S. Classic 14.475
Oksana Chusovitina Uzbekistan Gymnix EF 14.475
10 Coline Devillard France European Championships EF 14.466
11 Tabea Alt Germany German Worlds Trials 14.325
12 Boglarka Devai Hungary European Championships EF 14.316
13 Tisha Volleman Netherlands European Championships EF 14.250
14 Teja Belak Slovenia European Championships QF 14.216
15 Mai Murakami Japan All-Japan Event Championships QF 14.200

By the Numbers | Best Two-Vault Difficulty Combination

Rank Athlete Nation Meet Score
1 Wang Yan China Chinese National Games EF 11.4
Jade Carey United States U.S. Championships AA 11.4
3 Coline Devillard France Paris Challenge Cup EF 11.2
Sae Miyakawa Japan All-Japan Event Championships EF 11.2
5 Rebeca Andrade Brazil Varna Challenge Cup EF 11.0
Maria Paseka Russia Universiade QF 11.0
7 Shallon Olsen Canada Canadian Championships AA 10.8
8 Angelina Melnikova Russia Russian Cup EF 10.6
Boglarka Devai Hungary Paris Challenge Cup EF 10.6
Ellie Black Canada Universiade QF 10.6
Oksana Chusovitina Uzbekistan Doha World Cup EF 10.6
Tabea Alt Germany German World Trials 10.6
Tisha Volleman Netherlands European Championships EF 10.6
Mai Murakami Japan All-Japan Championships EF 10.6
15 Teja Belak Slovenia Szombathely Challenge Cup QF 10.4

By the Numbers | Average Score in 2017

Rank Athlete Nation Score
1 Sae Miyakawa Japan 14.800
2 Rebeca Andrade Brazil 14.631
3 Jade Carey United States 14.383
4 Shallon Olsen Canada 14.342
5 Tabea Alt Germany 14.325
6 Maria Paseka Russia 14.309
7 Coline Devillard France 14.283
8 Wang Yan China 14.280
9 Tisha Volleman Netherlands 14.032
10 Angelina Melnikova Russia 14.023
11 Mai Murakami Japan 13.988
12 Boglarka Devai Hungary 13.967
13 Ellie Black Canada 13.906
14 Oksana Chusovitina Uzbekistan 13.885
15 Teja Belak Slovenia 13.625

*Note that on vault where gymnasts are often upgrading or downgrading depending on the competition, averages are going to differ greatly from top scoring potential, though this nevertheless paints a pretty clear picture of who has been hitting most consistently.

Look out for our bars preview coming tomorrow, beam on Thursday, floor on Friday, and the all-around on Saturday, and we’ll also have profiles coming up to give you a glimpse into every gymnast who will compete next week. Additionally, we’ll be reporting live from Montreal beginning at podium training on Saturday, so be sure to keep your eyes open for live blogs galore!

Article by Lauren Hopkins

This post was made possible thanks to our amazing patrons who help us fund things like travel and video production as we work to grow the site. This month’s patrons: April, Daniel Bertolina, Emily Bischoff, Dodi Blumstein, Wendy Bruce, Katie Burrows, Kelly Byrd, Melissa Carwin, Jillian Cohen, Brittany Cook, Kat Cornetta, Kristyn Cozier, Anita Gjerde Davidsen, Holly Glymour, Hydrick Harden, Lauren Haslett, Inaya, Lauren Jade, Alexis Johnston, Katrina, Sarah Keegan, Ishita Kent, Alyssa King, Jenny Kreiss, Maria Layton, Rae Lemke Sprung, Leigh Linden, Annabelle McCombe, Stephanie McNemar, Bridget McNulty, Cindy McWilliams, M. Melcher, Alison Melko, Emily Minehart, Eyleen Mund, Rachel Myers, Melanie Oechsner, Jessica Olaiya, David F. Pendrys, Lauren Pickens, Cordelia Price, Abbey Richards, Christine Robins, Kaitlyn Schaefer, Lisa Schmidt, Brian Schwegman, Sam Smart, Stephanie, Karen Steward, Lucia Tang, Tipse_ee, Rachel Walsh, Laura Williams, and Jenny Zaidi. THANK YOU!

Want to help out and qualify for super fun rewards for as little as $1/month? Check us out on Patreon!

Follow The Gymternet on Twitter and like us on Facebook. 🙂

Advertisements

36 thoughts on “The Montreal Vault Preview

  1. Off-topic, but it will be interesting to see which members of the USA team are still major players after 2017, particularly with Maile, Gabby and Emma waiting in the wings (and of course, the possible return of Simone and Aly.) Ragan will continue but will face much stiffer competition next year. Jade could hang on if she cleans up her execution on both floor and vault. Morgan needs to be consistent. Ashton, sadly, seems to be the most likely to be replaced. Thoughts?

    Liked by 2 people

    • Morgan is most definitely the most likely to be replaced, not Ashton. Ashton with a 5.5 D score will obviously be replaced but if her D score increases, she can add .5 to the team total on bars. Morgan isn’t going to add anything to the team total if Maile/Gabby/Emma stay healthy. I would say Riley has a better shot of making a future team than Morgan does. Riley at least has bars as a standout event, which is unusual for a US all arounder.

      Like

      • Honestly, I think if Maile Gabby and Emma all can stay healthy and maintain (or even upgrade) in difficulty, even Riley will have difficulty making teams. Gabby has a stronger bars and AA set than her. Emma and Maile have similar strength (if not better) AA sets than her as well. These three juniors going up to the senior level will make it really tough for a lot of the current seniors to make teams in the future.

        Liked by 1 person

        • It’s not just about staying healthy.. Growth spurts are also a thing. An inch here or there could elimante one of these juniors. It’s funny because with an amanar, I could see Chiles/Carey becoming necessities for a worlds team next year. US seems covered for bars/beam.

          Liked by 1 person

        • the rising junior stars of last years were Foberg, Key, Ohashi, Priessman, Gaskins, Flatley : none of these ones had a senior future.

          Like

        • I honestly don’t see Perea making it. She’s had two major injuries already and she’s not even a senior. Malabuyo and O’Keefe are right with the best in the world right now but then again so was Ohashi and Key in their junior careers and we saw how well that turned out. I think Maggie will murder Riley before she can fulfill her potential, just like Foberg and very nearly Laurie. I’m not saying it’s all doom and gloom, we just can’t assume the three juniors will come up and become the new star(s) of USA gymnastics.

          Liked by 1 person

        • Zyxcba – Why did you say Maggie will murder Riley? Clearly didnt listen to the Gymcastic interview with her and AimeeB. #stopthelies lol

          Like

  2. When did the rules allow both a Yurchenko & Tsuk entry ? I was under the impression they were from the same category & thats the reason we haven’t seen them together .
    Thanks in advance .

    Like

    • No, Yurchenko and tsuk are different entries! The only time it’s not allowed is if the two vaults have the same flight…so a gymnast can’t do a Yurchenko full and a tsuk full because it’s a back layout full off the table, which is why Houry Gebeshian and Emily Little both got 2 point ND in 2016 (Emily at Pac Rims, Houry at the Test Event). But any Yurchenko/tsuk combo with different flights (e.g. DTY and tsuk full) is fine!

      Like

  3. My podium for vault (wishing and hoping) will be 1) Andrade.. it’s about time she won a world medal; 2) Jade Carey…. hoping she can really stick her Amanar for once and show what she has… she has so much potential, I really hope that she can make the podium; 3) Miyakawa of Japan or Wang of China. I don’t want to see Paseka on the podium. She has such bad form. I know she has the difficulty but I don’t want to see her ugly form anywhere near the podium. I hope that Shallon Olson can pull out a bronze at least if she hits… it would be great on home turf! When is podium training starting and when can we see videos?

    Liked by 1 person

    • Dear God I hope Paseka doesn’t even make the final! She has the worst form I’ve ever seen! She shouldn’t be within a mile of the podium. If you can’t do a vault without having your form look like regurgitated oatmeal, you aren’t a good vaulter

      Liked by 1 person

  4. “I am all about Rebeca Andrade of Brazil winning the gold. I’m really into this thing called execution, and if that’s the only thing that mattered, Andrade wins it hands down.”

    From your lips to the gym-gods ears.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. My dream podium:
    1. Andrade beacause clean execution should be PRAISEDDD
    2. Jade because she was just a L10 and I want her to hit
    3. Sae because I have been wanting her to medal since I saw her at the 2014 YOG but she will go OOB in her floor routine and crush my hopes

    Like

  6. Most of them performe a lot of these Yurchenko vaults, but I agree with one girl who said she wants more Tsuks and handsprings, also would be good to see different shaped vaults instead of twisting layouts too. 

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s