The Montreal Floor Final


The floor final in Montreal was quite possibly one of my favorite finals in recent memory. Why? Because Mai Murakami, certified goddess, finally won a medal.

Murakami’s career is one of close calls and near misses, and that wasn’t any less true for her this year when she placed fourth in the all-around final despite leading the field coming in. But in the floor final, the gold was hers to lose. She had the highest score this year, the highest average, the top hit rate, one of the highest potential start values…this final was all about Murakami, and it was such an incredible moment to see her pull off this epic win, becoming Japan’s second world champion in history, with the country’s last gold medal coming 63 years ago when Keiko Tanaka won the beam title in 1954.

I’ve said before that Murakami’s routine isn’t necessarily my favorite, but love it or not, she is a total package gymnast on this event. In this final particularly, there was a clear difference between gymnasts who could do one thing well on floor but were lacking in other aspects, and Murakami, who had it all — powerful and clean tumbling, strong dance elements, and fun choreography that fit the music and her personality well.

She was pretty much objectively the best floor worker this year, but that’s not a guarantee for a medal, let alone the gold. Murakami qualified second into the final, after Ragan Smith, whose ankle injury prior to the all-around final kept her from competing. The absence of Smith lessened the competition at the top, but Murakami still had to contend with Jade Carey, an incredible tumbler whose skill there overshadowed the areas in which she was lacking.

Things ended up getting super close between Murakami, who went up in the unfavorable first spot in the lineup, and Carey. Murakami’s routine was phenomenal on this day, with a stuck double double, small bounce on her double layout, perfect 2½ to front full, and a hop back on her double pike for a 14.233. But when Carey went up a few spots later showcasing the best tumbling she has ever done — including an open double double, full-twisting double layout, front double full to stag, and tucked full-in — I worried for Murakami.

Carey’s routine, as weak as it may be in terms of the choreography and performance value, was incredible. It’s insane that this kid made the turnaround from J.O. to elite so freaking fast, becoming a world-class gymnast on two events in only a matter of months, with the potential to do far more than what she’s already capable of. I wouldn’t have loved seeing her get the gold, just because the lack of artistry is such an issue at the moment, but I would’ve been happy for her had she won it, because the routine was truly that good.

But in the end, Murakami’s 14.233 held up ahead of both Carey, who got super close with a 14.2, and the rest of the field. It was Murakami’s time to shine, finally, after five full seasons of not making teams, not making finals, or not getting medals. Newcomer Carey, going two-for-two with medals in the first international meet (and third elite meet ever) of her career, will have time to perfect what she currently lacks.

She reminds me of Aly Raisman in 2010, back when no one expected her to make the floor final, getting last-minute artistry help from Martha Karolyi because her recycled routine was a mess. But then Raisman eventually came into her own on the event, and though her stylistic choices weren’t everyone’s cup of tea, she nonetheless made herself a better overall performer on floor, winning Olympic gold less than two years after her surprise first worlds final.

I can fully picture Valeri Liukin walking off the plane in Texas after worlds and immediately dialing every choreographer and artistry coach he knows. And because Carey is so coachable, the second she starts working with someone, we’re absolutely going to see her go from good to great. It’s coming.

In the past, I’ve never been fully behind Claudia Fragapane on floor, but then she went and got a Thoroughly Modern Millie routine, performing a sassy 1920s-inspired routine to the song “Nuttycracker Suite.” This is one of my favorite musicals ever, and Fragapane does the song justice, bringing in tons of her own personality. And on top of all that? She also fixed her tumbling. Tremendously. It’s like watching a totally different gymnast.

She was absolutely at her best in this final, and without the mistake on her opening full-twisting double layout pass, she would have presented a challenge for the silver or even the gold. But even with that weird stumble and missed jump connection, Fragapane pulled off the bronze because everything else was so freaking good. I was sitting there just blown away by how sharp and fine-tuned everything was. She wins my “most improved” prize on top of her medal, and in what has been a weak floor year overall, she and the other two at the very top made this final one of the best.

A pair of first-year seniors also helped to elevate this final with their brilliant performances, as Thais Fidelis and Brooklyn Moors finished fourth and fifth, respectively. With Fidelis, I was so impressed by her calm reserve after a frankly disastrous all-around performance, placing dead last in a field where she could’ve been top ten. But she simply showed up two days later for the floor final, performed a super clean and solid routine, and finished only a couple of tenths away from the podium.

Moors, meanwhile, had a star-making worlds performance. When she was announced for the team over two-time Olympian Brittany Rogers, fans of the Canadian team flipped out. I predicted and defended the choice of Moors over Rogers, frankly because Rogers simply did not make sense for this team at all, but many fans refused to believe that Moors would be able to pull off a strong enough floor routine to make the final, and because of this, they called her selection “pointless.”

It was anything but. From the moment she was introduced on floor in qualifications to the moment she sealed up her fifth-place spot in finals — Canada’s best worlds finish of all time on the event — it was clear Moors was quickly on her way to becoming a superstar. With fierce front tumbling — including a Podkopayeva and a front double full to front full to stag — and brilliant, effortless artistry, Moors is absolutely a star on this event, and as a gymnast.

Since the start of the year, Moors has improved by leaps and bounds in every aspect of the sport, and I have a sneaking suspicion that her confidence-building worlds performance — where the thousands of people in the crowd cheered for her with the same enthusiasm as they did for her three Olympic teammates — will be the awakening she needed to bring her from great to phenomenal. Moors is the future of Canadian gymnastics, and she’s only just beginning.

Lara Mori of Italy quietly and confidently came into this final not really as a frontrunner, and in a field full of stars on the event, it was hard for her to stand out as much, but don’t let that take away from what a fantastic job she ended up doing. The alternate for Rio last year, Mori was the only senior gymnast on the Italian team this year who really warranted spots on international teams, and she delivered both here and in the Euros floor final while also winning four domestic floor titles this season.

I don’t think Mori’s routine itself really speaks to her level of talent, as the music is kind of forgettable and that’s not something you can get away with, especially going up right after Moors as she did here. Her routine itself had some issues, like a stumble on her opening double layout and a messy, slightly under-rotated triple full, but it was a good enough routine even if she ended up being a little nervous or held back in many of her elements. I hope going forward, she can continue making small adjustments that will let her improve and maintain her status as one of Italy’s best.

At the end of an historic competition for two-time Olympian Ellie Black, she seemed super exhausted, especially as between competition days, she was writing school exams in her spare time. #JustEllieThings It showed with her fall on beam, and it also showed with her mistakes on floor, including a stumble at the tail end of her routine, a final she wasn’t even supposed to be in until Smith got injured and withdrew.

By this point, she just seemed ready to be done, and so while this wasn’t the best she could do, let’s just remember that Black ended up competing in four different finals, more than anyone else at this meet…and she nearly made the bars final as well. Black plans on continuing through to 2020, and hooray for that, because she looks better than she ever has, and I think she still has the ability to fix a few things looking forward to Tokyo.

Ending on a devastating note, Vanessa Ferrari, who never should have been in Montreal in the first place, decided to come into the final with her balls-to-the-wall difficulty, opening with a low double double before rupturing her Achilles as she punched from her whip into her tucked full-in. With a fully torn Achilles as she flipped through the full-in element, she had not a prayer in hell of landing the skill, finishing it on her hands and knees before calling for the medical staff to come over.

Ferrari, who has a history of issues with her tendon and had surgery to repair it following Rio, returned to competition just two weeks prior to worlds. At the final Serie A meet of the season, Ferrari performed lower-difficulty routines on beam and floor, and national team coach Enrico Casella immediately gave her a worlds team spot, leaving behind the healthy, albeit slightly inconsistent, Elisa Meneghini as well as several other viable healthy options in favor of the now 26-year-old Ferrari, who with her promised full difficulty would be a finals contender.

Who cares if your ankles are held together by strings if you can get into a final?! Totally worth it, right? It’s not as if the millions of Italian gym fans and bloggers (including myself) predicted disaster when hearing Casella’s choice to prematurely push Ferrari into major international competition for the first time in over a year. And when I saw Ferrari fall and not get up, I was heartbroken — but not surprised in the least.

Because she’s the kind of gymnast who in her mid 20s can remain competitive against gymnasts a decade younger, the Italian federation should consider themselves super lucky that they get to keep Ferrari around for her fourth quad after she played around with the idea of retirement during the Rio Games. But they’re not going to get her for Tokyo — and the qualification process leading up to Tokyo — if they destroy her already broken body by dumbly pushing her into competitions she’s not ready for and has no business being at.

My biggest emotion during Ferrari’s injury was “pissed off” because with every injury that happened at worlds this year, this one was entirely preventable and should not have happened. I’m gutted for Ferrari, but so incredibly mad at the people in charge who valued a finals spot over Ferrari’s health and well-being.

Can we also talk really quickly about Ferrari’s floor music being “O Fortuna” from the opera Carmina Burana? “O Fortuna,” the opening phrase of which translates to “Oh fortune, like the moon, you are changeable, ever waxing and waning, hateful life, first oppresses and then soothes, as fancy takes it” before continuing with “I bring my bare back to your villainy,” “Fate is against me in health,” and “Fate strikes down the strong man, everyone weep with me.” Vanessa, GIRL. Maybe go with “Girls Just Want To Have Fun” or something next year.

The two biggest misses on floor for me were probably Sae Miyakawa, who had the greatest level of difficulty but struggled with actually hitting her passes and finished 17th, and Wang Yan, who actually had a pretty great routine and could’ve challenged for a medal, but multiple out-of-bounds deductions pushed her into 11th.

Reigning Olympic bronze medalist Amy Tinkler also missed out by just about a tenth, placing 12th with a mostly great routine, and Giulia Steingruber, Catalina Ponor, Melanie De Jesus Dos Santos, Shallon Olsen, and Eythora Thorsdottir all got pretty close as well, coming into the meet as potential finalists, though not really frontrunners, so it wasn’t much of a shock to see them miss out. From this group, Olsen was probably the most impressive, if only because she normally is pretty messy and yet her qualifications routine was the sharpest I’ve ever seen her look. She still got pretty heavily deducted for some of her form, specifically on dance elements, but overall it was a great set for her.

We also got some lovely routines from the Germans, Tabea Alt and Pauline Schäfer, though neither had the difficulty to contend, Ana Derek and Cintia Rodriguez were gorgeous as always, the Belgians as always had super inventive and fun routines (Maellyse Brassart gets a special shoutout for her fantastic “come with me into the forest” bird routine), everyone loved Ioana Crisan‘s whip full in her opening pass, I lost my mind at the beauty of all of the Ukrainians here (Diana Varinska is clearly the standout for this team, but both Valeriia Osipova and Valeriia Iarmolenko were beautiful on this event in particular!), and Yoana Yankova of Bulgaria stood out with a tremendous performance, despite the rough spots in her tumbling.

Morgan Hurd showed in the all-around final that her floor could’ve been a contender, and while she would’ve been two-per-country’ed out of the final with Smith and Carey ahead of her, with Smith’s injury, Hurd could’ve taken over her spot had she hit, so it was a bummer that the floor mistake — her one mistake all competition long — kept her from making yet another final.

Others who had falls and missed out despite having potential to make the final and even medal included Yesenia Ferrera and European champion Angelina Melnikova. I think with Ferrera, she just needs more experience. She competed exactly twice in a three-year period, so is it all that shocking that she can’t pull off strong sets at major international competitions? Come on, Cuba. Get it together. With Melnikova, a foot injury was apparently the cause for her poor floor performance both in qualifications and in the final, which is a shame as she has the kind of routine that could’ve done very well here.

That wraps up our recaps and thoughts on the women’s events at worlds! You can get the full results here, and also be sure to check out the photo gallery. Coming up, we still have many thoughts about the men, and we also have our breakout stars recap of the gymnasts who made a name for themselves in Montreal.

Article by Lauren Hopkins

This post was made possible thanks to our amazing patrons who help us fund things like travel and video production as we work to grow the site. This month’s patrons: April, Daniel Bertolina, Emily Bischoff, Dodi Blumstein, Wendy Bruce, Katie Burrows, Kelly Byrd, Melissa Carwin, Jillian Cohen, Brittany Cook, Kat Cornetta, Kristyn Cozier, Anita Gjerde Davidsen, Holly Glymour, Hydrick Harden, Lauren Haslett, Inaya, Lauren Jade, Alexis Johnston, Katrina, Sarah Keegan, Ishita Kent, Alyssa King, Jenny Kreiss, Maria Layton, Rae Lemke Sprung, Leigh Linden, Annabelle McCombe, Stephanie McNemar, Bridget McNulty, Cindy McWilliams, M. Melcher, Alison Melko, Emily Minehart, Eyleen Mund, Rachel Myers, Melanie Oechsner, Jessica Olaiya, David F. Pendrys, Lauren Pickens, Cordelia Price, Abbey Richards, Christine Robins, Kaitlyn Schaefer, Lisa Schmidt, Brian Schwegman, Sam Smart, Stephanie, Karen Steward, Lucia Tang, Tipse_ee, Rachel Walsh, Laura Williams, and Jenny Zaidi. THANK YOU!

Want to help out and qualify for super fun rewards for as little as $1/month? Check us out on Patreon!

Follow The Gymternet on Twitter and like us on Facebook. 🙂


21 thoughts on “The Montreal Floor Final

  1. Not related to the floor final, but WHY did Morgan Hurd change her ending choreography? Possibly my favorite bit of choreo across all gymnasts and all routines.


      • It gave her a tenth in her d-score! And given the results of the AA final, a veryyyyy worth it tenth!!! (I still cant get over that the AA final was actually super close!)


    • Literally the worst possible song choice. I did a production of “Carmina Burana” when I was in college so when I heard her song choice I was like ooh YAS! But then was like oh wait that song is…the worst possible choice for what eventually happened to her hahaha. VANESSAAAAAA.


  2. The funny thing is that the Italian federation ( Enrico Casella), still defends the decision to bring Vanessa. While literally everyone was worried for her health, he told everybody that her body was fine ( yet Vanessa told to the media that after the podium training all parts of her body were hurting) and that what happend was just bad luck. He refused to take responsability for the most predictable injury ever, and Ginnastica Italiana also slammed many fans because ” you’re not doctors, Vanessa was fine and she was unlucky like Ragan and Larisa, maybe it’s the equipment’ s fault”. How can you let your gymnasts compete that difficulty when she had to stop training just a few weeks before Worlds?? Also, she never EVER trained the complete routine with both the double double and the whip+ full in!

    Liked by 1 person

    • Omg LORD. She literally has surgery on her tendons like 300 times a year?! Vanessa’s injury is basically the only one that was NOT the fault of the equipment!!! And Larisa’s in a sense, but I don’t think Larisa knew she had any previous problems with her Achilles tendon specifically even though she talked about “heel pain.” But yes, super bad decision, Vanessa was NOT READY, and no matter how much he tries to defend the decision, it was a dumb one.


    • The guy is a moron. So arrogant. Poor Vanessa, the one who is now suffering from his stupid decision. She’s now out for who knows how long because she was pushed into going for a floor medal she had little chance of getting anyway, against fit and strong Murakami, Carey, Fragapane, Moors, etc. I love how the federation are telling other people they’re not doctors when Casella was the one who tried to lift Vanessa up and take her off the floor WHILE THE MEDICAL TEAM WERE STILL ATTENDING TO HER.


      • I’m not entirely blaming Vanessa, but she did have the power to say that she wasn’t ready to compete at Series A, which also would’ve taken her out of world contention, and she also could’ve turned down the worlds spot. She’s not a young, impressionable first year senior, she’s 26 and knows better than just about anyone else that it’s far more important to stay healthy than risk everything for one event Final. As a former world AA champion as well, she had nothing to lose nor prove, and I think she also could’ve spoken up or done something to not go to worlds. Its not an easy decision for anyone to turn down a worlds spot, regardless of age or prestige, but this could very well be the thing that could potentially end her career or beat her down going into Tokyo, and while Casella absolutely takes most of the blame for this and should feel ashamed of his idiotic decision, I still feel that even Vanessa should’ve seen this coming.


        • Sure, she could have should have said no, but Casella’s attitude here was really concerning. Just because she’s 26 doesn’t mean she isn’t susceptible to pressure from coaches. It’s hard to put your foot down when someone is pushing you to go to a meet, when you know it’s the one year Simone isn’t around and when you know you’re not getting any younger. She may have been afraid that if she didn’t do this, she wouldn’t have a spot next year or ever again…who knows? She deserved more support than this.


    • Simone was not there this time, so we don’t know if she would have won or not, and nobody knows what may or may not happen in a year? They won on their own merits not because another person was absent.

      Liked by 1 person

  3. Both Vanessa and Casella said that right after her turn he told her that if she had done her full difficulty passes she could have gotten the gold. Does that seem realistic to you guys? That’s definitely the reason why she went for the whip whip full in..


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s