European Championships Reactions: The Senior Team Final

Screen Shot 2018-08-06 at 11.36.13 PM

Coming into this year’s European Championships, knowing France was at full strength while the Russians came to Glasgow with injuries on injuries, I fully gave France the edge to take the title here.

Seeing the French women lead the field in prelims with a near-perfect day compared to the Russians counting three falls (two on beam, one on floor), it was clear that France truly did have the edge because, as always, Russia’s biggest drawback was not its talent, but rather its lack of consistency. Without counting those three falls in prelims, the Russians would’ve had a healthy lead and they were still very clearly a contender for the gold, but I didn’t trust that they’d actually pull it off. Why? Because they never do.

Over the past decade, most of Russia’s wins and medals have been by default. High difficulty, weaker competition from countries at meets like European and World Championships, and the occasional appearance from Queen Aliya Mustafina are generally what keeps them afloat, but now faced with some truly strong up-and-coming programs, it’s not as easy to win or medal with falls, especially when a good chunk of the top girls are out with injury.

I didn’t have a lot faith for Russia to get the gold this week. As thoroughly impressed (and emotional) as I am by the Angelina Melnikova renaissance this year, the rest of the team didn’t match her level in prelims, and to come out on top here, everyone had to be operating at maximum potential. While France looked physically fit, mentally strong, and super together in prelims — where they topped the Russians by a little over two points — the Russians seemed a little lacking and didn’t look like they’d magically be different by the final.

Oh, but they were.

Starting on vault, the Russians created a half-point lead with some huge difficulty, even if none of their current vaulters are all that clean. Their pair of Rudis from Lilia Akhaimova and Angelina Simakova followed by Melnikova’s solid DTY ended up matching the lower-difficulty but much cleaner vaults from the French girls in prelims, but in the final, they were able to come out ahead after the French gymnasts were a bit weaker than expected.

Marine Boyer opened France’s rotation on vault with a clean but simple FTY, and Coline Devillard ended it with a Rudi that was a bit messy in the legs but had more power than those from the Russians. Mélanie De Jesus Dos Santos, the unofficial all-around champion this year, looked a bit rushed and not nearly as clean as we can generally expect to see her, though, and she ended up finishing with a wild bounce back, looking a bit disappointed to not hit the way she knows she’s capable of doing.

Though Russia is typically known as “the bars team” at most meets, the French girls were actually superior here as a team in qualifications, and the two squads were going to work out pretty evenly here unless one of the teams had errors…which the French again did.

After anchoring vault, Melnikova hit her bars with a mostly clean set, fighting a muscled inbar half into her piked Jaeger and coming up short on the handstand before her toe full to full-in dismount, but she came up with a 14.033, which Uliana Perebinosova matched after looking a tad messy and rushed at the beginning, but she composed herself and the latter half of her routine was very clean in comparison, with just a tiny step on her full-in.

Capping off the rotation was recent national team addition Irina Alexeeva, who was invited to Round Lake this spring and moved from WOGA, her gym in the U.S., to fight for a spot on international teams this year. After missing the Russian Cup due to injury, Alexeeva ended up getting a spot over 2012 Olympian Viktoria Komova, which was a major shock, but it was clear why they trusted her when we saw her in this team final. After getting two-per-country’ed out of the bars final, finishing just a tenth behind Melnikova in prelims to finish seventh overall but third among the Russians, Alexeeva ended up being the top earner in the team competition, posting a 14.233 for her tidy routine.

France got off to a rough start on bars in the final, where Lorette Charpy — who has hands-down been the most consistent gymnast in the country, if not the world, on every event in the lead-up to Euros this season — arched over the toe full to stalder at the start of her routine, her first miss on the event among her 12 routines since falling at worlds last year. Though she recovered nicely, catching a piked Jaeger and Ricna before dismounting with a clean double layout, she was only able to bring in a 12.533 to the team total.

The two who followed her, De Jesus Dos Santos and Juliette Bossu, both hit very well, looking just a bit cleaner than all of the Russians. Bossu, a specialist on this event right now as she deals with an injury that’s keeping her from doing her thing on floor, hit her inbar full to Chow half, a huge piked Jaeger to Pak, and a high double front for a 14.200, while De Jesus Dos Santos began her routine with a perfect Galante to Pak before going on to show immense attention to detail in the rest of her skills, nearly sticking the full-twisting double layout to bring in a 14.400, the highest bars score of the team final.

With Russia leading by over a point and a half going into the halfway point, beam absolutely had the power to change the course of the final. If everything went as it did in prelims, France would easily be able to catch up. It’s no secret that beam is generally where things fall apart for the Russians, with the ladies counting falls in basically every team final I can remember, and the last time they were in Glasgow, this event was what cost the team a medal at worlds, with all three competitors falling.

But not today, Satan. Alexeeva, who fell on her flight series in prelims, absolutely nailed her daring layout stepout mount directly into a layout stepout, going on to also attack her flight series, showing zero problems throughout the rest of her routine, putting up a 13.233, a score that would’ve challenged for a medal in the apparatus final.

As great as her routine was, her score was bested by both Simakova and Melnikova, which was so incredible, and one of the best moments of the meet when the team realized just what they’d done here. Simakova was excellent on her flight series and big double tuck dismount, and Melnikova opened with an insanely good punch front mount right into her jump series, wobbling slightly on her flight series and full L turn, but bringing back the control for the rest of her set, which she finished with a beautiful double pike.

This is truly where the Russians won it. Even if France was perfect in their final two rotations to continue the challenge, the Russians truly would’ve needed to bomb floor to give up the gold.

After the surprise hit from the Russians, despite being the more talented beam team, France unfortunately gave up what they needed to fight, finishing more than a point behind the Russians on the event. Charpy came back from her bars fall to deliver a slightly nervous but hit routine to lead off the team, and De Jesus Dos Santos looked incredible on her punch front mount, punch front pike, layout series, and a high double tuck, posting a 13.600, second-best in the team final on this apparatus.

Their beam queen, Boyer, had a true bummer of a performance here, bouncing off on her layout series on top of looking a bit nervous and wobbly on some other elements. The 2016 Olympic finalist on this event, Boyer posted just a 12.166, finishing with a strong double pike, but the damage had been done, and the Russians went into the final rotation with a three-point lead, meaning the title was almost certainly theirs.

Russia kept up their razor-sharp focus in the floor final, once again winning the event after fabulous performances from Simakova, Akhaimova, and Melnikova. Simakova showed precise dance and tumbling, finishing her routine with a solid double pike and double tuck; Akhaimova opened with a big double layout and fought through some weak landings on her double arabian and double tuck; and Melnikova ended the competition for Russia with a strong full-twisting double layout, a stuck double layout, a step back on her front tuck through to double tuck, and a low double pike with a good cover on the landing, earning a 13.533 to seal the gold.

Charpy returned to once again lead off for France in the final rotation, but she sadly sat her opening double front, and just like her bars fall, this was quite a shock, as she hasn’t really missed on this event much at all this season, with worlds her weakest performance prior to this. I talked about her incredible consistency prior to this meet because it’s so impressive for someone to compete so often (this was her eighth big meet of 2018) without major mistakes, which is exactly why she was counted on to lead off three events, so it was heartbreaking to see her not at her best here.

Coming back from a beam fall of her own, Boyer did her best to get the team back on track on floor, hitting all of her passes well, and then De Jesus Dos Santos had a lights-out routine to wrap things up, sticking her full-twisting double layout and also nailing her full-in double tuck and double pike, earning a 13.966, the highest floor score at Euros this year.

It may not have been enough to touch the Russians, and the team ended up finishing more than four points behind the gold medalists, but the silver is France’s best team finish in history at European Championships, beating their bronze medal finish in 2016…counting three falls! I think they should take comfort in knowing that even without the falls, because Russia was just so good, it really was Russia’s day and likely would’ve been even if France was also on fire, so the fact that they could hold onto a silver medal standing with everything that happened is just a testament to how strong they are as a team right now.

Over the past two quads, France has gone from a program that struggled to put a team together after tons of injuries in 2012 and one that was in danger of falling short of qualifying to the 2016 Games to one that is now challenging some of the best programs in the world, with the ability to easily finish in the top five at World Championships in Doha this fall. It’s a super exciting time for them, but while I really was pulling for them to get the upset in Glasgow, the Russians absolutely outdid themselves with one of the most complete team performances in as long as I can remember, with France doing a tremendous job to keep up with them and light that fire under them after prelims.

The Dutch team ended up being a surprise for bronze here, really taking advantage of Great Britain’s injuries and weaker lineups by putting up a beautiful performance to get the first team medal for the Netherlands since they won silver in 2002.

After placing fifth in prelims, the Dutch women got their first taste of luck when the third-place Belgians withdrew from the team final, but overcoming the British — the reigning world bronze medalists competing at home in Glasgow — wouldn’t be easy, especially after counting a fall in that first rotation when Vera Van Pol missed her Kochetkova.

Celine van Gerner also wasn’t at her best on that event, but Sanne Wevers hit a beautiful set with her front aerial to split jump to Kochetkova and her dance series both done incredibly well, setting the tone for the rest of the meet with a 13.700. Everyone performed beautifully from that point on, with some highlights being Van Pol’s solid vault and bars sets, Van Gerner’s flawless floor and bars routines, Wevers’ beautiful work on bars, Tisha Volleman‘s quintuple pirouette to double pirouette on floor and big DTY on vault, and first-year senior Naomi Visser’s incredibly clean FTY on vault.

The team was happier than any other team when they realized they’d end up on the podium. It was very unexpected coming into the meet, and seemed likely but still a challenge after seeing them in prelims, but in the end, the British girls ended up being their only real competition for that medal, and our favorite #TheForceIsGrace squad was able to finish more than two points ahead of the host country to win the bronze.

Great Britain started out strong on bars, with Kelly Simm and Georgia-Mae Fenton both showing difficult and clean work, as Simm hit her toe full to Ray, Ricna to Pak, and Chow to Bhardwaj while Fenton looked excellent on her Derwael-Fenton to Ehzhova and Maloney to clear hip to Ricna to bail to toe full series, all of which was incredibly clean (and it was, of course, a shame that Fenton missed out on the bars final knowing she can do what she did in the team final, though I was thrilled that Simm ended up getting in).

Both Fenton and Simm ended up struggling on beam, though, with Simm’s beam especially heartbreaking, showing falls on her leap series and hop full turn. “I will learn more from this one bad routine than any of the seven other good ones this week,” Simm said on social media following the competition, adding that she was so proud of how the team came out to finish strong for the rest of the meet. I loved her attitude both in that post and in seeing her words in action, getting over her disappointment on beam super quickly to come back and cheer for her teammates. It’s the attitude of a true leader, and the team was lucky to have her there to make sure they regrouped to finish strong.

Commonwealth Games beam champion Alice Kinsella was one of those sources of strength, fighting through a couple wild moments on beam to end up hitting her set, and then she, Fenton, and Taeja James — who didn’t compete in prelims after coming onto the team last-minute following Becky Downie’s injury — were all solid on floor while Simm, Kinsella, and Lucy Stanhope were excellent on vault, putting up the second-highest score of the day on that event thanks to Simm’s Lopez and a set of DTYs from Kinsella and Stanhope, with Stanhope’s especially gorgeous in the air and in the landing.

Many teams here are dealing with a ridiculous number of injuries, but the British girls have been hit especially hard, with the country’s four top gymnasts currently rehabbing and fighting to come back for worlds. In the absence of this top-tier group, Simm continues to do a fantastic job leading this younger generation of gymnasts, and though it didn’t end up going exactly the way they’d hoped, like the French girls, they still managed a very strong finish despite counting several falls into their total, again a testament to the strength and strong comeback of the team.

The rest of the teams that competed in the final — Ukraine in fifth, Italy in sixth, Spain in seventh, Hungary in eighth — didn’t have much of a shot at medaling in the way the top teams did, finishing about five points back from the top half of the field, but all had several great moments and fought through tough adversity just to be here.

Ukraine, qualifying eighth into the final, counted a couple of falls and mistakes, including from Diana Varinska on bars and Angelina Radivilova on floor, two events where they were expected to be standouts. Both had strong moments too, though, as did Yana Fedorova on bars, and Valeriia Osipova competing all four events.

Osipova proved to be a real up-and-comer at this meet after starting to show signs of potentially being a strong contributor last year, and a little more polish to her could be great for Ukraine as the team continues its rise back up to the top. This was Ukraine’s first time making the team final at Euros since 2010, and it’s just the beginning for them, especially with some strong new seniors coming up in the next couple of years.

The Italians didn’t initially make the final, but when Belgium withdrew, they came in as the first reserves. It was bittersweet, as the team lost vaulter Sofia Busato to a knee injury in prelims, but the four who ended up competing in the final did their best to fight for a strong finish, and though they really struggled on bars, beam and floor went surprisingly well.

After a mostly strong day, beam was where Spain fell apart a bit, though Cintia Rodriguez was excellent there and on floor, while Ana Perez had an absolutely gorgeous FTY and a fantastic bars set with some great connection work, a piked Jaeger, and a full-twisting double layout with a little hop to lead the team there with a 13.300.

Finally, Hungary started out with a couple of mostly great rotations on beam and floor, with Dorina Böczögö looking practically better than ever on these two events, while I was also super impressed with first-year seniors Nora Feher on beam with her full Y turn and solid flight series and Sara Peter on floor with her strong triple full to open. Boglarka Devai added a strong score to the team’s total with her solid DTY on vault, but while both Feher and Noemi Makra hit good routines on bars, Böczögö ended up falling twice in her routine, on her stalder full and then as she stumbled back and sat the dismount, a sad ending after an otherwise excellent day for her.

Results from the senior team final and all of the other sessions at European Championships are available here.

Article by Lauren Hopkins

This post was made possible thanks to our amazing patrons who help us fund things like travel and video production as we work to grow the site. This month’s patrons: April, Dodi Blumstein, Wendy Bruce, Kelly Byrd, Jillian Cohen, Kristyn Cozier, Holly Glymour, Hydrick Harden, Inaya, Lauren Jade, Alexis Johnston, Katrina, Sarah Keegan, Ishita Kent, Jenny Kreiss, Rae Lemke Sprung, Leigh Linden, Annabelle McCombe, Bridget McNulty, Cindy McWilliams, M. Melcher, Alison Melko, Emily Minehart, Eyleen Mund, Melanie Oechsner, Jessica Olaiya, Cordelia Price, Abbey Richards, Christine Robins, Kaitlyn Schaefer, Lisa Schmidt, Brian Schwegman, Stephanie, Lucia Tang, Rachel Walsh, and Jenny Zaidi. THANK YOU!

Want to help out and qualify for super fun rewards for as little as $1/month? Check us out on Patreon!

Follow The Gymternet on Twitter and like us on Facebook. 🙂

Advertisements

23 thoughts on “European Championships Reactions: The Senior Team Final

    • But that would have left huge holes in vault and bars and even floor. Alice is CWG champ and Kelly bronze. (And neither Latalia or Maisie medalled in that final). They took people who can hit beam 90% of the time and also put up good scores elsewhere, rather than those who can hit 95% and are weaker elsewhere. Just bad luck.

      Like

    • Well the British team were really decimated by the injuries to the entire “A team” of Ellie Downie, Becky Downie, Claudia Fragapane and Amy Tinkler. It was also a major blow that Becky picked up an ankle injury after Euros podium training – originally she was meant to do bars and beam.

      Like

    • Maybe Amelie Morgan will help solve the beam problem next year. I also hope the GB selectors persevere with some of the younger gymnasts and don’t automatically revert to the so-called A-team when they are fit unless they earn their places. If they can improve their consistency Kinsella, Fenton and James have great potential. I don’t think Becky Downie would have altered the result here, her beam’s usually pretty meh and looking ahead to Tokyo there’ll be no place for her in a team of 4 all-arounders. Time to look to the future.

      Liked by 1 person

      • Agreed. Amelie was great, so I hope she can transfer over to the senior ranks ok.

        The frustrating thing is, there are several GB women who are good on beam. Alice, Kelly, Georgia, even Ellie and Amy can score OK. The problem is their consistency is way too low, and they need to fix it, as a priority, if they want to be in with the big dogs.

        Like

  1. Do you think irina alexeeva has a shot at making the world’s team. If so and she hit like she did in team finals in world’s prelims and hit again like that in bars and beam finals, how do you think she would place. I was wondering with this success she might move to round lake temporarily orr has she already done that

    Like

    • Valentina Rodionenko said that all the girls on the Euros team “significantly improved their chances of being selected for the worlds team”. Also keep in mind that we will most likely see Alexeeva upgrade beam and put floor back in, she had recently injured her knee so she had to downgrade a bit at Euros.

      Liked by 1 person

    • She definitely does! I think she more than proved herself here, and think she could also go up on floor, where she’d be likely to outscore Akhaimova or Simakova once she’s back at full strength. She is already at Round Lake (has been for several months) and is working with the coaches there now.

      Liked by 1 person

    • Barring an injury, I’d be very surprised if Alexeeva was left off the World’s team. She’s clearly proven herself at Round Lake, & despite her 1 fall in prelims, she excelled when it counted in the team final. I also wish she hadn’t been 2 per country’d out of the bars final!!

      And according to an interview when the team arrived in Glasgow, Valentina appreciates, & doesn’t hold against her (like I honestly thought she may), attributes she has that may seem “American”… Quote: “Her mentality is American, in a good way.”

      Like

  2. What a difference a year makes. Melnikova has gone from the inconsistent gymnast who apologizes to everyone after a botched performance to the new leader of a young team lacking in their most experienced veterans, who was their rock on every single event. I mean Melnikova hit every single routine. I don’t think that’s happened for her since 2014 jr. euros.

    Liked by 1 person

    • It is absolutely INCREDIBLE to see Melnikova’s progress from Rio to now! I’ve been in awe witnessing her incredible journey to get to the consistent, strong leader that she now is, & she continues to rise on my ‘favorites list’!

      Her mental toughness has really improved… almost seems like she worked with a sports psychologist, but well it’s Russia, & no, they wouldn’t have that… but whatever she’s doing, it’s working, & I LOVE IT!

      In a somewhat similar vein, I’ve also loved watching Kelly Simm step up to become such a solid leader for the British team when they really needed someone to step up! I hope that even when the A-team comes back, she is given opportunities & her value is not overlooked.

      Like

      • I agree about Simm and hope she doesn’t take the rap for effectively putting GB out of medal contention. As mentioned in my earlier post I also hope the others in the Euro team are given more opportunities and that the A-team aren’t blindly selected based on past achievements. They need to prove that not only are they fit but that going forward they have more long term potential than those who have been carrying the team in recent competitions.

        Liked by 1 person

    • During the Russian cup, the coach of Nabieva and Eremina commented the live streaming and delivered a ton of informations about the girls. She seems to be a very sensible and mindful person and she spoke about all girls in a very kind way. She said that last year, Melnikova was not so involved in training, she didn’t work so hard and that she thought about leaving the sport. Bur, finally, she decided herself to persevere and she is really a new person, much more determined and extremely hard-worker.

      Like

  3. While this may seem a good result for Russia, their lack of starpower on single events is actually quite worrying. All girls are rather “bland” with average ability on less or more events, which is confirmed by the fact that only Melnikova won a couple medals in EF (which she never would/will in Worlds). This is in contrast with Russian tradition which was to blow out in TF but have great medal potential in EF (Paseka VT, Spiridonova UB, Afanasyeva FX, Kharenkova BB, Mustafina UB/BB/FX). They are giving up on starpower for bland consistency and this is NOT a good development.

    Like

    • I agree completely. Where is the WOW factor? I used to love Russian gymnastics because they combined beauty with the hard skills/EF worthy routines. Now it’s like “eh.”

      Like

  4. Also I have to say Russian execution is rather worrying: what’s up with all the form issues and loose legs? Looking at you Melnikova.

    Like

  5. Congratulations to the Russian women. 12/12. I never would have believed it. Now I may have to admit that Valentina knows what she’s doing.

    I love the French team. What charismatic and talented young women! I know it’s been said before, but MDJDS makes me think I’m watching a young Dominique Dawes. I hope Melanie gets on the podium at worlds.

    Ukraine! Ukraine! Ukraine! Wow, what a difference Ostapenko makes. Their WAG program has resurrected in less than 2 years.

    Like

    • I also love the French team. They seem so supportive of everybody too- Coline in VT finals being so happy for Devai was wonderful to see. And MDJDS will be a star for them. I really like her on all apparatus.

      Like

  6. Melanie DJDS is so clean on every event ! I particularly love her bars and deplore she was not qualified for the bars final (2 per country rule). She also got twice the best all around score, during qualifications and the team final, each time outscoring Angelina Melnikova. Do you think she can have a bronze medal at the next world championship all around final ?

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s